cast: Amitabh Bachchan, Abhishek Bachchan, Aishwarya Rai , Tanisha Mukherjee
Directed by Ram Gopal Verma
release date: JUNE 06, 2008
When you see the Balaji Films banner flash, you know some fears pop up. And with SARKAR RAJ I have to admit that most of my fears did come true. After all the setting was just right...it is a sequel, so you have some basic characters already well established. For now it was just a matter of Ram Gopal Verma filling up the template that he once successfully created.
Hence SARKAR RAJ does what every sequels does...recreate the atmosphere of the original, play around with the characters from the original, introduce fresh characters into it like those Balaji teleserials, get some out, bring some more in...and the game goes on. And it could not get any better, if the game is one of politics.
We join the Nagre family where we left off....Sarkar (Amitabh Bachchan) still is the supremo but the man who is really running the show is his son Shankar Nagre (Abhishek). And together they keep the Sarkar name running.
To this perfect scenario comes a multinational company who wants to start a plant in rural Maharashtra. Though senior Nagre is not happy with the proposal of the company's CEO Anita Ranjan (Aishwarya), the beta Nagre thinks otherwise. He sees the potential of such a project and knows how benefical it is in the long run.
So Shankar convinces the Sarkar household, and then goes on to educate the villagers with Anita in tow. However things are not so straightforward...as the plant suddenly becomes the object of attention. Political forces all emerge from all corners, both high and low, for a share...and the intentions are not always like what they seem to the eye.
But fighting all setbacks, beta Shankar is all fired up on making this project a reality and will go travel the distance to make this a possibility. However....
Yes , last time the media was certain that this is about the Thakereys. But eventually inspite of the Bachchan character of Subash Nagre being a Bal Thakerey ripoff, the film was essentially what Ram Gopal set out to do - a desi Godfather. Though this time Ram Gopal Verma wants to prove that he still got it in him. And so he ensures that this is not an extension of any Godfather series. Hence RGV sticks to politics this time. However he takes on Indian politics big time.
But what Ram Gopal Verma really presents here is not just any family of power. A detailed look and we know the inspirations are the ruling family of India itself. While many of the audiences might just lap it up at face value...(.that is the Bachchan household redefining the term 'family drama'), there are still a lot that will instantly recognise that the history books are being thrown at their faces. In fact RGV also tries to touch at some controversial 'conspiracy theories'of the partition era without getting into any major trouble. Smart.... And eventually Sarkar Raj saga does leave us with an update of the current political scenario...an outsider lady taking over the reigns of power, while a grandson is being prepared to carry forth the dynasty.
But this is the Nehra dynasty with a Mumbaiyya touch, all jumbled and mumbled into the Sarkar template that I spoke about earlier. Caricatures of villains that fail to really bring about a sense of grave danger to the proceedings. Though characters played out by Govinda Namdeo, Sayaji Shinde, Upendra Limaye all start out strong, in the end they are just sidenotes in this enterprise.
Aishwarya Rai was just a shameless add on. The whole Anita-Shankar track seems terribly forced. Obviously if it was not for the real life references that Ram Gopal Verma was trying to make, this was a character that could have been done away with. To start with she is hardly the woman of substance that all the pre-publicity hype was making her character to be. Surely Ramu, there is more to such a woman than just a shirt unbuttoned look. However Aishwarya's character of Anita hardly had anything substantial about her and is disappointing when you consider her impressive outing in Jodhaa Akbar.
Abhishek Bachchan continues from where he left off last time. His eyes still breath fire, and the man delivers in his rather cold approach to the proceedings. However while he stole the show the first time around, it is Amitabh who gets the better cup in this trip. Eventually the senior Bachchan tries to redeem the legendary tag of his from a debacle like AAG in a big way. And RGV makes up in a sense for the loud Babban with this calmer Subash Nagre. The film again shows why Amitabh Bachchan is a class actor!
Also one must say how impressive the new find of the RGV stable is ...Rajesh Shringarpure. With just a few scenes, he creates an impact that was certainly missing with Kay Kay not being there this time around. But unfortunately his character fails to live up to its potentiality. So expect a similar fate to that of Kay Kay's.
Technically you know that a Ram Gopal Varma movie has a different look and feel to it. Though at one time it was cutting edge advancement, the same cannot be told these days with everyone catching up. However RGV still retains his stamp...be it on the music, the screenplay, the angles, the feel. Yet one cannot help feeling how over indulgent he gets with these mediums. He lets Amar Mohile go wild with his ear scorching background score, while Amit Roy seems to be a lot excited getting to toy his camera. There is a lot of that in-your-face approach, that you wonder if the aim of the game is to count the wrinkles on the stars faces. Some of the key moments definitely could have done away with that. But Ramu thinks every part of an actor's body has a say in acting...right upto the nostrils. Editing is also a mixed bag. At times it looks top of the notch while at times it gets shoddy and RGV maintains the lethargic pace of the original. Oh yes, this is a sequel, remember?
Irrespective of all that, this is still one of the finer attempts from Ram Gopal Varma in a long time. However it would be going overboard if I claim that RGV is back in a grand way. Because at the end of the day, for some one like Ram Gopal Varma this is just one of those exercise routines where he got more things right than wrongs. But never does it ever pose a threat to the list of his materpieces. For we all know that RGV is a director capable of much more.
With Sarkar Raj what he manages essentialy is to maintain the solid punch and feel that he delivered the first time around. Thus in that RGV can sigh a relief. Yet it is obvious that this one deserve a trilogy style follow up to wrap things up. This is one that RGV can easily pick up and take the series for a third go.
But for the time being, here is a rather pleasing and fitting sequel that ties up to the original in a much better way than the namesake Bollywood sequels of these days do! And as for Ramu, after all those holidays, I think with Sarkar Raj, he is definitely back at work!
MoviemagiK gives it a 3 outta 5
THE PANEL ROOM
Well, getting the usual suspects together to see their verdict on the RGV sequel...it seems that though they haven't not ripped it apart like they usually do...most of them still ain't impressed with this one. And once again Taran as most of the film's this year, loved the flick. All in all, we find this SARKAR RAJ ending up at halfway point with a 2.6/5
SARKAR RAJ supersedes the prequel and most importantly, RGV bounces back like never before. An outstanding film in all respects -
Taran Adarsh 4/5
comeback may be a strong term. The film still marks Ramu returning gradually to his roots. Mayank Shankar 3/5
Sarkar Raj is recommended only for those in need of a depression pill. Khalid Mohammed 2/5
This is a watchable, entirely forgettable film, and fans of the original are advised to rewatch that one again. RajaSen 2/5
an average rating for Ram Gopal Varma's Sarkar Raj, it's a disappointing follow up to a very good film. Rajeev Masand 2/5
